2023 Impact Factor
Bipolar disorder is a mental disorder that fluctuates between depression and mania [1]. This severe, recurrent, and disabling disorder causes devastating consequences to individuals, families, and society [1,2]. Therefore, early disease detection is required to prevent subsequent mental and physical deterioration [1]. Ideally, preventive measures would reduce the disease and symptom severity and enable a cost-effective treatment [3]. However, there is usually a long delay between the onset of affective symptoms and treatment initiation [2]. The risk of bipolar disorder may be estimated by personal attributes and family history [4-6]. For example, individuals with a first-degree relative of bipolar disorder are at five to ten times elevated risk of first onset of bipolar disorder in adolescence and young adulthood than those without a first-degree relative of bipolar disorder. However, the questions remain unanswered regarding the risk and timing of the recurrence of affective episodes for individuals who have bipolar disorder.
The concept of disease prediction has long been proposed and studied intensively [7,8]. Theoretically, there are two ways to predict the likelihood and time sequence of the recurrence of bipolar affective symptoms: (1) monitoring of the progression of signs and symptoms and (2) mining of the tract of historical data. Routine monitoring of disease signs and symptoms is the simplest way to evaluate the current and recent status of diseases. However, the sensitivity and specificity of such approaches are limited to the experiences of mental health professionals. In addition, most studies investigating the prediction of the onset of bipolar affective symptoms are based on the existence of specific phenomenology and the course of prodromal symptoms [9-11]. The main difficulty for implication would be the requirement of mental health specialists to monitor the progression of prodromal symptoms of a considerably large number of vulnerable indivi-duals. On the other hand, converting biochemical indica-tors (e.g., regular measurements of hemoglobin A1c and glucose/lipid levels in diabetes patients) into smart indicators using the telecommunicating system has shown success in alerting the potential onset of certain chronic diseases enabling earlier interventions [12-14]. Given that physical comorbidity negatively affects the outcomes of bipolar disorder [15,16], modeling clinical data during the previous affective episode, including both psychiatric and physical characteristics, may potentially predict the onset period.
In this study, we explored whether historical data, including psychiatric assessments, physical examinations, laboratory tests during psychiatric hospitalizations, might predict the duration to next admission of bipolar disorder. To be convincible, we chose bipolar I disorder instead of bipolar II disorder because the latter was relatively difficult to diagnose [17] and might be underdiagnosed. We tested the performance of two models: (1) the clinical symptoms model and (2) the all-in-one model.
The research protocol of the current study was approved by the Joined Institute Review Board, Taipei Medical University (File number: 201312054). No written informed consent was required as approved by the review board.
We obtained the data from the computerized medical records of the patients receiving treatment in Taipei City Psychiatric Center (TCPC), a mental health center with 300 acute beds and 312 chronic beds for the Northern Taiwan catchment region of 7 million people. We initially identified 572 potential subjects based on the following criteria: (1) having had at least one psychiatric admission to TCPC between January 1, 2006, and December 31, 2014; and (2) having the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems 9th Revision (ICD-9) code 296 on discharge. Afterward, two board-certified psychiatrists (Pao-Huan Chen and Chi-Kang Chang) independently reviewed the medical chart of each potential subject to confirm the psychiatric diagnosis. Subsequently, we identified 328 subjects with a final diagnosis of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 4th edition (DSM-IV) bipolar I disorder. To establish the prediction models for the duration to next admission because of an acute affective episode, we analyzed the data of 101 subjects who have had at least five psychiatric admissions due to recurrence of bipolar disorder, which resulted in 717 acute psychiatric admissions.
A structured case-note form has been utilized in the TCPC since 1980 for recording patients’ demographic data, clinical features, concurrent physical illness, family history, results of physical examinations during psychiatric hospitalization, and laboratory tests routinely conducted in the morning after psychiatric admission following overnight fasting. A total of 141 clinical variables were available from the dataset. Multiple measurements were anticipated for most of the variables, and the missing information due to patient behaviors, disease progression, limitations on the national insurance reimbursement, and clinical considerations during admission.
We conducted an exploratory analysis to select variables that contributed to the duration to next admission. The selected variables were then examined in the clinical symptoms model and the all-in-one model.
We defined the duration to next admission as the time length between admission-j and admission-j +1 of the ith patient as follows:
d: time point of admission (date)
The numerator of the above formula is divided by 7 to obtain a week quantity. The duration to next admission was used as an independent variable in the following regression analyses.
We presume that if an independent variable indeed contributes to a dependent variable (i.e., outcome), then the exclusion of a small part of the data of the independent variable would not affect its association with the dependent variable. Thus, we conducted a robustness sampling procedure. For each independent variable, one of the admissions of each patient was randomly excluded, and single variate regression was conducted on the remaining data using a mixed model. The process was iterated 1,000 times. The mean results of the independent variables, which demonstrated a higher number of observations than that of the duration to next admission (i.e., 616 observations) and with a pvalue smaller than 0.05, were retained and used in further multivariate regression. We exponentiated the beta coefficient to obtain an odds ratio for ease of judgment.
A mixed model multivariate regression with a forward stepwise approach was used to examine the relative contribution of the independent variables, which showed significant contribution in the individual regressions mentioned above using the summated duration to next admission:
In which,
βk: beta of covariate-k
χijk: covariate-k at j-admission of ith patient
εij: error of each patient
All statistical analyses were conducted using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute).
This study analyzed data of 101 patients with bipolar I disorder (71.3% female, Table 1) [18]. During a mean illness duration of 31.6 ± 9.8 years, the mean number of psychiatric admissions was 8.2 ± 3.1 times. Among psychotropic medications used for the treatment of bipolar disorder, lithium (90.1%), valproic acid (84.2%), and atypical antipsychotics (92.1%) were the therapeutics most frequently prescribed in this study sample. More than half of the patients had cardio-metabolic comorbidities.
Table 2 summarizes the results of 25 single-variate regressions with statistical significance. For the continuous variables, the following variables were negatively associated with the duration to next psychiatric admission: age of onset, total psychiatric admission, length of atypical antipsychotics use, body mass index, systolic pressure on the 1st, 2nd, 3rd day of hospitalization, and the discharge day, diastolic pressure on the 1st day of hospitalization, pulse pressure on the 1st, 2nd, 3rd day of hospitalization, and the discharge day, and percentage of monocytes. On the other hand, the length of lithium use and heart rate on the 3rd day of hospitalization and the discharge day during the psychiatric hospitalization were positively correlated with the duration to next admission. Among categorical variables obtained during the psychiatric hospitalization, mixed episodes, obesity, hyperlipidemia, and diabetes mellitus were negatively correlated with the duration to next admission. In contrast, lithium use, carbamazepine use, mood congruence, psychotic features, and the last duration to the psychiatric admission were positively correlated with the duration to next psychiatric admission.
Eight variables that are clinically helpful to characterize bipolar disorder and were with statistical significance in the single-variate regressions (i.e., age of onset, total psychiatric admission, mixed episodes, mood-congruent psychotic features, length of lithium use, length of atypical antipsychotics use, carbamazepine use, and lithium use during the psychiatric hospitalization) were included in the clinical symptoms model. The results are summarized in Table 3. Four of these variables, namely age of onset, total psychiatric admission, length of lithium use, and carbamazepine use during the psychiatric hospitalization, were retained in the model. All retained variables posi-tively contributed to the duration to next psychiatric ad-mission. Interaction analysis of the age of onset and total psychiatry admission showed a positive contribution to the duration to next admission, meaning that when one of the interactive items (age of onset or total psychiatric admissions) is fixed, an increment of the other item reduces the duration to next admission.
Table 4 summarizes the results of multivariate regres-sion for the all-in-one model. All significant variables in the single-variate regressions were entered into the multivariate regression, and five variables were retained. The only variable that demonstrated a negative correlation with the duration to next psychiatric admission was hyperlipidemia, meaning that hyperlipidemia during the psychiatric hospitalization shortened the duration to next admission. The rest of the four variables—last duration to the psychiatric admission, lithium use, carbamazepine use during the psychiatric hospitalization, and heart rate on the discharge day—were positively correlated with the duration to next admission.
We identified four variables positively attributable to the duration to next psychiatric admission in the clinical symptoms model. The association suggests that patients with bipolar disorder who have an older age of onset, higher numbers of psychiatric admissions and carbamazepine use, and longer lithium treatment are more likely to have a longer duration to next psychiatric admission. That is to say, the patients would stay in a stable condition longer than those with opposite features. We found five variables attributable to the duration to next psychiatric admission in the all-in-one model. Among them, hyperlipidemia was the only biochemical variable retained and was negatively associated with the duration to next psychiatric admission. The association suggests that the duration to recurrence of bipolar affective symptoms was likely to be shorter when hyperlipidemia exists. The positive correlation of carbamazepine and/or lithium use means that patients with bipolar disorder who used these two therapeutics had a longer duration to next psychiatric ad-mission. Also, patients with a faster-beaten heart during the remission phase had a longer duration to next admis-sion.
Several naturalistic studies have demonstrated the exacerbating nature of the variables retained in the clinical symptoms model of our current study, for example, the unstable lithium monotherapy [19] and early-onset age [20]. Despite a lack of significant role of glucose dysregulation in predicting the time to next admission in our study, its demanding role in modulating the illness course of bipolar disorder is prominent. Several genetic studies have revealed the associations of glucose/insulin metabolism-related genes and the development of bipolar disorder [21-24]. Supporting evidence has also been reported in studies investigating the biochemical profiles in patients with bipolar disorder. Coello et al. [25] found a higher rate of metabolic syndrome in newly diagnosed bipolar disorder patients compared with the matched healthy controls; Mansur et al. [26] found an association between impaired glucose metabolism and earlier age of onset, longer illness duration, and higher frequency of previous manic/hypomanic episodes and the ratio of manic/hypomanic to depressive episodes in patients with bipolar disorder; Cairns et al. [27] reported six bipolar disorder patients with a previously episodic, relapsing-remitting course of illness experienced a worsening of morbidity after the onset of insulin resistance, suggesting that insulin resistant may be a modifier in the progression of bipolar disorder from a treatment responsive (episodic) to a non-responsive (chronic) course of illness. These implicate that bipolar disorder patients with glucose dysregulation are difficult to treat. Indeed, bipolar disorder patients with impaired glucose metabolism were more resistant to lithium and mood stabilizer treatments [28].
The role of lipid abnormality in the development or recurrence of bipolar affective symptoms is less mentioned in the literature. Nevertheless, emerging evidence has revealed that dysregulated lipid metabolisms may play a role in the pathophysiology of bipolar disorder [29,30]. Several hormones that regulate lipid metabolisms, e.g., leptin [31], resistin [32], and ghrelin [33], are associated with the stability of bipolar disorder [30]. In a sample with 30 bipolar disorder patients in a manic episode and 30 controls, Tunçel et al. [30] found that higher leptin and resistin levels were associated with acute manic episodes while higher ghrelin levels were related to a euthymic status. In our study, hyperlipidemia was negatively associated with the duration to next psychiatric admission. The results indicate that a normal lipid profile favors mental stability, and lipid dysregulations lead to the progression of bipolar disorder. Certainly, the normal lipid profile may reflect a lower use of antipsychotics and mood stabilizers in patients with minor psychopathology or better drug treatment. Whether the lipid abnormality represents a part of the pathogenesis of bipolar disorder or an outcome of antipsychotic use remains to be investigated.
In bipolar disorder, a faster heart rate is possibly related to an up-regulation of the autonomic nervous system (ANS). This can be deduced from the findings of a naturalistic study on 23 patients with bipolar disorder that duration and onset of bipolar disorder were associated with a down-regulation of ANS [34], which partially explains why patients with a faster heart rate on the discharge day had longer duration to the next admission. Another plausible explanation is the involvement of genes in both the development of bipolar disorder and the regulation of cardiac activity, e.g., the calcium voltage-gated channel subunit Alpha1 C-gene (CACNA1C) [35,36]. In a sample of 170 euthymic patients with bipolar I disorder genotyped for CACNA1C rs1006737 and underwent a 3T three-dimensional structural magnetic resonance imaging scan, Soeiro-de-Souza et al. [37] found that the CACNA1C minor allele A carriers exhibited a greater left medial orbitofrontal cortex thickness and an age-related cortical thinning of the left caudal anterior cingulate cortex compared to the non-carriers. Importantly, this gene also regulates heart rate. McCarthy et al. [38] investigated the association between electrocardiographic parameters and CACNA1C genotypes in 59 patients with bipolar disorder and found that heart rates by genotype GG, GA, and AA were 76.1 ± 2.3, 69.4 ± 2.0, and 62.6 ± 2.1. We speculate that bipolar disorder patients in our study who demonstrated a shorter duration to next admission might consist of specific brain structural abnormality (greater left medial orbitofrontal cortex thickness and age-related cortical thinning of the left caudal anterior cingulate cortex) and be more likely to carry the minor allele A. This hypothesis remains to be tested in future studies. Another direct question is if lithium affects heart rate in a dose-dependent manner. The current evidence indicates that lithium may induce a list of cardiac abnormalities, including T wave inversion, sinus node dysfunction, sinoatrial blocks, PR prolongation, QT prolongation/dispersion, ventricular tachyarrhythmias, ST-elevation myocardial infarction, heart blocks, and the Brugada pattern [39]. Nevertheless, current evidence is insufficient to indicate an apparent dose-dependent effect of lithium on heart rate.
The results of this study should be interpreted in the context of several limitations. First, some patients might not have been admitted during an affective episode, possibly because the symptoms were mild or tolerable, unnoticed, or less disturbing (e.g., very mild mania), and even when the symptoms were severe. Thus, a recurrence does not mean an admission. Second, only patients who had at least five psychiatric admissions were used in this study. The purpose of this decision was to increase the power of prediction. However, this might have limited the implication to those with frequent admissions. Third, we excluded the variables with observation numbers smaller than that of the duration to next admission for multivariate regressions. This criterion was arbitrary and might have had decreased the performance of the regression models. Nevertheless, a balance between the use of reliable information and sensitivity must be reached. Fourth, the multicollinearity of variables was not examined in the current study. Thus, whether the predictive variables were mutually correlated cannot be excluded. Nevertheless, this issue has little influence on the conclusion because we aimed to identify any variables that predict the out-come. Fifth, a psychiatrist may prescribe lithium or carbamazepine over valproic acid and atypical antipsychotics to the patients in certain clinical conditions such as mixed features and dysphoric mania. This question would require a further definition of a weighted or mediator model to pinpoint the answers.
In summary, the time to recurrence of bipolar disorder is theoretically predictable because the parameters lay along a timeline and are related to each other. Our study identified essential variables predicting the duration to next psychiatric admission in patients with bipolar I dis-order. Besides alerting a possible psychiatric admission, the models examined in this study revealed the interplay between cardio-metabolic health and bipolar disorder, especially the all-in-one model, which showed that a faster heartbeat and a favorable lipid profile are related to the delay in the next mood episode. Further studies are warranted to examine whether manipulation of mechanisms beneath these associated phenotypes improves the outcome of bipolar disorder.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
This study was supported by a grant provided by the Taipei Medical University, Taipei, Taiwan, for newly employed teaching staff (TMU107-AE1-B05) and a research grant from the Ministry of Science and Technology, Taiwan (MOST 104-2314-B-038-022).
Conceptualization: Pao-Huan Chen, Chun-Ming Shih. Data acquisition: Chi-Kang Chang, Chia-Pei Lin. Formal analysis: Yung-Han Chang. Clinical Advise: Hsin-Chien Lee. Funding: Pao-Huan Chen, El-Wui Loh. Supervision: El-Wui Loh. Writing−original draft: Pao-Huan Chen, Chun-Ming Shih, El-Wui Loh. Writing−review & editing: El-Wui Loh.